gwendolyngrace: (Wee! Winchesters)
gwendolyngrace ([personal profile] gwendolyngrace) wrote2008-06-26 07:09 pm

Fifty Percent: Part Five

Fic title: Fifty Percent
Author name: [livejournal.com profile] gwendolyngrace
Artist name: [livejournal.com profile] sazzlette
Genre: (rps, wincest, het, gen) Gen / Het
Pairing: John/OFC
Rating: R
Word Count: 46,450, Posted in 5 1/2 parts
Warnings/Spoilers: (if applicable) Told in two eras: 2007 and 1989. The 2007 storyline is set between “Bad Day at Black Rock” and “Sin City”; the flashback sequence references “Something Wicked.”
Summary: While cleaning out John’s storage locker, Sam finds an envelope from his father addressed to someone from their past. Dean objects to delivering it, but Sam happens upon a hunt that takes them practically to her doorstep. Could they be demons released when the Gate opened? In 1989, shortly after the shtriga hunt, the Winchesters settle in small-town Ohio while John figures out whether or not he can keep hunting. Beverly Kirkland, the children’s librarian, meets the boys and their father. After a chance encounter with John, she reluctantly grows closer to him, all the while wondering what it is about the family that doesn’t quite add up….
Author’s Notes: So many things about this, but I don’t want to give stuff away. Right. Well, first off, I had this in my head long before “Supernatural: Rising Son” came out, and before I found out that Jeffrey Dean Morgan and Mary-Louise Parker were a couple (and then they broke up before I finished drafting this). The idea came up while I was writing Trost und Freude for a holiday exchange - but takes place *before* that in the Wee!chester timeline. I’m very grateful to [livejournal.com profile] sazzlette for her art of awesome (10 sketches, count'em OMG! - AND a music mix!), [livejournal.com profile] etakyma for her unfailing willingness to read what I’ve written and tell me how to fix it, [livejournal.com profile] july_july_july for her incredibly insightful beta-reading, and Wikipedia for lots of helpful information, ranging from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles collectibles to the names of Kansas Governors to facts (and missing information) about our MOTW.
Link to fic: Part One, Part Two, Part Three-A, Part Three-B, Part Four, Part Five

Back to Part Four


~*~NOW~*~

“Well, one thing’s for certain,” Dean said when they got back to the car, “if we don’t catch this thing in the next two days, someone else’ll be getting ganked in a week.”

“We don’t know that anyone will die,” Sam said. “Barker could have been a fluke. But it’s a good bet that someone here in Toledo will wind up in Columbus.”

“At Lowell’s Tavern, no doubt.”

“Yeah.”

“Super,” Dean complained. “So now we’re so far ahead of this thing that we have to wait for it.”

“Well, hang on,” Sam muttered. He was looking at the picture of Barker’s tattoo—or whatever it was—he’d snapped with his phone. “We may be able to anticipate something about the next victim. I know I’ve seen that symbol. Recently.” He reached over the bench for his laptop bag and booted up the computer.

“Where are we going, Sam?” Dean asked.

“Hang on a second.”

Dean ignored him and pulled out, but Sam saw why when he looked up. An unmarked car was parking right near when they had been sitting. Dean drove a few streets away until he found a Starbucks and parked.

“Want anything?”

Sam shook his head, pulling up some of the files he’d been looking at the night before. Dean climbed out.

“Dude, you might as well be staring at hieroglyphics, man,” Dean said, rolling his eyes as he stomped away.

Sam’s head popped up to watch Dean’s back through the driver’s window. Hieroglyphics! He remembered where he’d seen the symbol before, and it wasn’t on his computer. He dug through the satchel for the photocopied pages. By the time Dean returned with coffee, Sam had found the page. “I knew I’d seen that symbol. Look.” He held out the page with its table and tapped on the seven little triangles in their double row. “It’s cuneiform, Sumerian writing, Dean. It’s the symbol for five.”

“Five?” Dean frowned. “But there’s seven of ‘em.”

“Yeah, the Sumerians used two triangles, one on top of the other, as the symbol for zero.”

Dean swiveled his head toward him. “How could you possibly know that?”

Sam opened his mouth, closed it, and opened it again. “I…saw the books in Lauren’s room and…I got curious.”

“So you just happened to look this stuff up, what, today? Yesterday?”

The corner of Sam’s mouth twitched. “Today,” he confessed.

Dean stared at him.

“Stop looking at me like that.”

“Dude, you are seriously freakish sometimes.” Dean started the car. “Okay, it’s the symbol for five, and it’s Sumerian.”

“Yeah, and I think the name Namru is, too. Hang on,” Sam flipped through the stack of paper. “I think I saw something when I was photocopying. We can stay here and look through this stuff, or we can head back down to Columbus and try to find this Mike, Mark, Malcolm guy.”

Dean pulled out. “We’ll be in Columbus in two hours, dude. Research fast.”

After an hour on the road, Sam looked up from his stack. “Yeah. Namru—he was a god of resurrection and science.”

“And five?”

“Well, numerologically speaking, the number five symbolizes life, regeneration, identity, and the self. And sometimes, nothingness.”

Dean sucked his teeth, but thankfully declined to take an easy shot at Sam’s esoterica. “Okay, so anything involving the god Namru is likely to have a lot of fives hanging around it?”

“I guess, and the spirit of a suicide is definitely the combination of nothingness and self.”

“I suppose,” Dean murmured. “So, have you figured out what’s going on?”

“No, but I know if we can find this guy at Lowell’s, we might be able to stop it.”

“Awesome.” Dean blinked at the road. “Huh,” he said, as if a thought had just struck him.

“What?”

“Well, I just realized. Columbus to Cleveland? Toledo to Columbus. Same distance, man. Hundred and fifty miles.”

“Seriously?” Sam said—not because he didn’t believe Dean on driving distances, but because he couldn’t believe it hadn’t occurred to him, either. “Where’s the map?”

Dean jerked a thumb toward the back seat. Sam unbuckled his seatbelt and hung over the bench to dig around. Dean protested immediately, “Get your ass out of my rearview!” but Sam ignored him. He found the map (after making sure Dean would regret smacking him on the back of his thighs) and flopped back into the seat. To his vast amusement, Dean was unrolling his window as fast as possible.

“What the hell, man?” Dean was griping.

“Hang on,” Sam said. He refolded the map to show both Toledo and Cleveland at the top and Columbus at the bottom, and traced a direct line from each northern city down to the southern one. “Holy shit,” he said. “It’s a Roman numeral five, Dean.”

“Oh, now that’s just weird,” Dean said.

Sam scoffed. “Everything we’ve ever done, and this is what’s weird for you?”

Dean opened his hands on the wheel to shrug. “Whatever.”

They made it back to Columbus well before the end of the workday. Dean headed straight for Lowell’s. They flashed Gareth’s picture at the bartender—a different one from the night they’d come around asking about Lauren’s bar fight. “Was this guy in here a little less than a week ago?” Dean asked brusquely.

“Maybe,” he said. Sam handed him a twenty. “Yeah, he was here. Talking to Mitch.”

“Mitch?” Sam echoed.

“Mitch Fallon,” came the answer. “He comes in every couple days.”

“Okay,” Dean said in a professional tone, “could you point him out if he comes in?”

The bartender crossed his arms. “Mitch is a regular. If you’re looking to mess him up—”

“No, no, no, no, no,” Sam said quickly. “Honest, we just need to talk to him. He was with a friend of ours who went missing a little while ago.”

Dean reached for his wallet and pulled out a fifty. “Just bring us a couple shots of tequila if he comes in tonight, okay?”

“If he comes in,” the guy said dubiously. “He’s usually studying on Tuesday nights.”

“Studying?” Sam asked. This was a biker-bar, not a hot spot for intellectuals.

“Yeah, he’s a grad student at OSU.”

“Do…you know what he’s studying?”

The bartender shrugged. “Uh…I dunno, something about ancient history? Linguistics? Something like that.”

“Mesopotamian history?” Sam pressed.

“No idea.” He moved down the bar to pour for another customer.

They sat; they ordered. Dean decided darts were the thing and talked Sam into throwing a round with him. About an hour and a half later, a group of guys walked in. They were dressed in leather like most of the others, except that they leaned toward the Goth end of the spectrum, with spiked hair, eyeliner, and a few choice piercings alongside their dog collars, jackets, and biker gloves.

The bartender’s eyes flicked over to Sam and Dean, then followed the threesome as they took up a booth near the back.

“Look alive, think we’re up,” Dean said, slapping Sam’s arm with one hand while tipping up his beer with the other.

Sure enough, a few minutes later the waitress, who looked like she could double as a bouncer, if necessary, brought over two shot glasses of tequila. “Larry says these are for you two,” she announced with disapproval. “He said they don’t go on your tab,” she added, in a way that threatened that they’d better be reflected in her tip.

“Yeah, we, uh, we paid for ‘em when we came in,” Sam told her through his best boyish smile. One of their marks came back to the bar to pay for a billiard rental and headed back to the others.

The waitress harrumphed and moved on to other tables. Dean looked at Sam for a moment, head cocked, then he wiggled his eyebrows once and launched out of his chair. Sam watched him go to the bartender and return a moment later with a rack of billiard balls and two cues. “C’mon, Sam, let’s go,” he said as he passed their chairs. Sam nodded. He thought he had an idea of what Dean had in mind. He grabbed their beers, leaving the tequila untouched, and joined Dean to play his shill.

“Did Larry tell you which one is Mitch?” Sam asked Dean when he got to the table.

“Yeah,” Dean answered, not looking at the other group at all. “Nebbishy guy in the crewneck, not playin’—jus’ watchin’.” He set up the balls and broke, all business.

Sam could shoot pool almost as well as Dean, but since he’d hit a growth spurt in tenth grade, he’d hated the game. The billiard table was always too low for him. By the time he set up five shots, his back began to complain from the constant leaning over. So he usually left the hustling to Dean. But occasionally, Dean needed help hooking his fish, so either Dad or, more recently, Sam, had to set up the take. They’d put themselves through an average round of eight-ball, each one shooting a couple scratches and a number of outright misses, until the mark they wanted to grift took notice—and took the bait.

Dean had set up at the next table over from Mitch and his friends, which they in turn had chosen because it was near the booth where they had stashed their jackets and messenger bags. His friends seemed old for Goths, but they still rocked the black eyeliner and the leather with too many zippers. Mitch was dressed like them, but didn’t wear it as easily. He reminded Sam of a kid still learning how to be comfortable in his own skin.

After Dean sank his third scratch on an attempted side pocket shot, Sam saw that Mitch was watching their game more than his buddies. He was following Dean’s hands, as if memorizing the rhythm of their travel would improve his own game. Sam decided it was time to reel in the fish.

“Man, you suck,” he said loudly to Dean.

“Oh, bite me,” Dean replied genially. “I’m just not warmed up yet.”

“Yeah, whatever. More beer?” Sam asked.

Dean grunted, drained his mug, and handed it over. As Sam headed for the bar for refills, he heard Dean call to Mitch, “Hey, how about you, man? You play?”

When Sam got back, Dean was racking up the balls and Mitch had taken Sam’s cue.

“Sammy, this dude’s gonna show you how it’s done,” Dean announced. Though his voice sounded friendly to anyone else, Sam could hear the tightness in it.

“Oh, probably not,” Mitch said. He was certainly more of a nerd than the others, especially for in here. Sam thought of that unfortunate scriptwriter back in Hollywood—Walter. He’d thought he could dabble in controlling spirits, too, and it had got him killed. He’d been motivated by a desire to use knowledge of the supernatural for fame. What was it about guys who seemed so harmless on the outside? Sam guessed maybe they’d been pushed one too many times around the schoolyard. Sort of the supernatural equivalent of Columbine killers.

Mitch held his cue too tightly, so that it skipped off the cue ball when he tried to put English on it. Dean was going to have to trash his game just to give Mitch a chance. Dean noticed it too, from the way he raised his eyebrows and widened his eyes slightly when Sam handed him his beer.

“Oh, hey, Mitch, this is Sam,” Dean said, not bothering with an alias, but also not explaining who “Sam” was, giving him room to work an angle.

Mitch waved, index finger extended and the rest of his hand curled loosely. “You guys, uh, passing through, or what?”

“We’re visiting our aunt,” Sam said. “Just…there’s only so many evenings with the relatives that you can take, I guess.”

“What about you, Mitch?” Dean asked, deliberately missing a slot shot on the five-ball. “This doesn’t exactly look like your kind of place.”

“Yeah, it’s cool, right?” Mitch said, looking around. “I can’t stand college clubs. Everyone’s such a poseur, y’know?”

His friends agreed loudly. Dean fought back a broad smile and Sam could tell he was suppressing a smartass remark.

“Oh, you’re in college?” Sam asked to make conversation before Dean’s resistance broke down. He wondered how long they’d have to maintain the friendly act before they could separate him from his pals. Sam was certain they were no threat, but if they were all regulars, the last thing he and Dean needed was to fend off an entire biker bar. Especially one that had just seen a nasty fight a couple weeks ago.

“Grad school,” Mitch corrected. “I’m studying Ancient Mechanics.”

“Come again?” Dean said with a head jiggle.

“Ancient Mechanics. I’m sort of making up my own program. It’s a combination of anthropology, ancient languages, and physics.”

“To do what?” Dean pressed. “Figure out how to bring back that Mohawk?” He pointed at Mitch’s friend’s hair.

Mitch glanced at his friend, but didn’t seem to understand that Dean was twitting him. “Uh, no. I’m looking at the way ancient cultures believed the world worked and um, through that, how they conceived of and responded to technology—wow,” he interrupted himself. “That was some shot.”

“Huh?” Dean looked down. He hadn’t been paying attention to screwing up his pool game and he’d just banked off the end bumper, skittering the nine and the three toward the side pockets. The nine slid off the table and sank; the three was lined up perfectly.

“Oh. Flukey, huh? Wow,” Dean observed of his own performance. He over-cocked the angle so that when he shot, the ball had too much backspin and it rolled wide of the three.

“So…ancient mechanics?” Sam picked up on the interrogation. “Like how ancient?”

“Well, as far back as I can go. Antiquity and pre-antiquity, really. I mean, Greek and Egyptian, sure, but I’m more interested in the Mesopotamian cultures—Sumeria, Akkadia, Chalcedon, that kind of thing.” He lined up his shot and took it; his ball didn’t go in, but it did mess up Dean’s next lineup for the three.

“That’s pretty obscure,” Sam said.

“Yeah, but there’s new stuff getting discovered all the time,” Mitch said. His eyes lit up and he became much more animated. His enthusiasm made him relax a lot more, and Sam found him smart, funny, and pleasant when he forgot to act cool. He nattered at Sam about his thesis proposal and the fantastic book he’s just got three and a half weeks previously from a rare dealer.

“I mean, technically, it should be in a museum, right? Not my apartment. But man—it’s just amazing. The kinds of dedications they made to Namru—he was their god of science and resurrection. See, his priests believed that all mechanical devices had life forces that kept regenerating, which is how they kept working continuously. Did you know that they had all the elements necessary for an internal combustion engine?”

“Izzat right?” Dean commented. “What do you know—you say you got this about three weeks ago?” He wasn’t looking at Mitch, though; he was looking at Sam. Sam returned Dean’s angry stare with a grim nod.

“Yeah, just about.”

“Wouldn’t happen to be in—what’s the word, Sam—”

“Cuneiform.”

“Cuneiform, right. It wouldn’t happen to be in their glyphs, would it?”

“Well…yes,” Mitch admitted uneasily. “It’s a transcription of several monuments and tablets. The book was hand-drawn by a Cistercian—”

“Okay,” Dean cut him off. “Let’s cut to the chase. Mitch, have you been…translating the book?”

“Well, yeah. It’s part of my dissertation—”

“And have you been reading it out loud?” Dean pressed urgently.

“Uh…y-yes.”

His friends picked up on Dean’s accusatory tone. “Problem, Mitch?” one of them asked, trying to be menacing.

“I…don’t think so, Mark,” Mitch said. Sam looked at Dean.

“Your name is Mark?” he asked.

“Yeah.”

“Are you a grad student, too?” Dean said. Sam could tell he was trying not to be a smart-ass, but he just couldn’t help it.

“Yeah, so?” Mark asked.

Sam pulled out Gareth Barker’s picture. “Do you know anything about this guy?”

Mark stared at the photo. “No,” he said flatly.

“Yeah,” Mitch said. “Don’t you remember, Mark? He was here…like a week ago? I took his business card.” He moved to the booth and flipped open his bag. “He was interested in my theories about mass-production using ancient designs as inspiration.”

“Huh.”

“Yeah, I…have it here, somewhere,” Mitch fished for the business card, shambling back toward them.

“Why are you looking for this guy?” Mark asked.

“We’re not. He’s dead.”

Mitch fumbled the card. It fluttered out of his hand and he leaned heavily against the pool table.

“Dead?”

“He showed up in Toledo yesterday and blew away two people before getting shot by police. The thing is, Mitch, or Mark,” Dean said, facing off against both of them, “you guys might have been the last people to talk to him.”

“Are you cops?” Mark asked.

“We’re investigating his death,” Sam supplied. “Mitch, we have reason to believe that, crazy as this sounds, his death and your book are connected. Can you take us to see it?”

Mitch shrugged. “Well, yeah, but you can’t read Sumerian, isn’t gonna do you much good. Are you serious? This isn’t like, Punk’d or something?”

“We’re serious, Mitch,” Sam told him grimly.

Mitch shook his head. “I don’t understand. Why should you think I had anything to do with this guy? He died in Toledo.”

Dean crossed his arms. “Because witnesses said Barker was talking about Namru,” he snapped. “Now, since that’s not a word that generally comes up in casual conversation, and you happen to have a lot to say about this Namru guy, we thought we’d just ask you a question or two about the book.”

“Yeah, we…just thought you might have some information,” Sam added to soften Dean’s impatience.

Mark shrugged. “They want to ask questions about whether an ancient pagan god has something to do with a random guy’s death, Mitch, I say make sure they pay you for it.” He turned back to his pool game.

Mitch, meanwhile, had gone a bit pale. He glanced at Mark’s back, then said quietly to Sam, “I didn’t know…I mean, I just thought…what’s the harm?”

“Mitch, what’d you do?” Dean demanded, voice low, but loud.

“Let’s…go to my apartment. I’ll show you.”

Mitch rode in the back and gave Dean directions to his place. When they entered, he made straight for the side table. Sam saw candles, a small idol in the shape of a lion-headed god, a collection of herbs in a shallow bowl…. “An altar? You built an altar?”

“To Namru, yeah,” Mitch admitted. “But I didn’t think it would mean anything. I just…thought it’d be cool, y’know? A little immersion.”

“Mitch, people have been disappearing,” Sam said urgently. “They go missing, and then five days later, they turn up committing some awful crime. Why is that, Mitch? What’s in this book that makes them do that?”

“What!?” Mitch said, completely shocked and looking a little shaken and scared. “No, that’s—that’s impossible, that’s not what the ritual—”

“Ritual?” Both Dean and Sam said at the same time. “What ritual?” Sam barked.

“Uh…the ritual I found. It’s supposed to…uh, make the caster…well, y’know. Attractive. To women. It’s supposed to grant vitality and longevity.”

“And you’ve been conducting this ritual?” Sam concluded.

“Y-yeah. It says you’re supposed to recite it once per week for five weeks. The first part captures spirits and holds them in Limbo, watching over you from beyond. After five days, you light the candle and finish with a second incantation, and that…that releases the spirits back into the world. Oh, god. You can’t seriously think that it’s real?”

“Oh, it’s real,” Dean said confidently. “What’s more, your little spellwork is costing people their freedom and their lives.”

“Look,” Sam said, pulling Mitch to sit down so that he could explain. “You did the ritual for the first time three weeks ago, right? That same night, you summoned a spirit. The spirit of someone who’d committed suicide near where you were.”

“Namru collected the souls of suicides so they could be reborn,” Mitch muttered.

“Yeah, genius move, there,” Dean groused.

Sam waved him off to calm him down. “That spirit, I don’t know why, but it didn’t come here to you. It possessed someone else at the bar. David Owen.”

Mitch put his head in his hands. “This is impossible.”

“No, it’s not, Mitch. Look, you said five days later, you release the spirit?”

“Yeah.”

“Well, five days later, David Owen showed up outside of Cleveland, a hundred and fifty miles away. He committed an arson, and when the cops arrested him, he had no idea where he’d been or what he’d been doing.”

“Coincidence,” Mitch insisted. “And why would he go to Cleveland?”

“This sounds nuts,” Sam agreed, “but spirits don’t usually like to be summoned back. We think they tried to get away from you. Maybe a hundred and fifty miles is as far as it took to break free, or maybe that’s as far as they could go. It could even be that when you sent them back, they came back…off target, or something. We don’t really know. But we do know that they believed a violent act would force them out of their…host bodies.”

Mitch gaped at him. “That is the craziest thing I’ve ever heard.”

“You’ve been reciting the ritual,” Dean said suddenly. “You didn’t translate it, did you?”

“Well, I…I looked it over before I used it,” Mitch said. “I transliterated it into phonetics.”

Dean looked over Mitch’s head to Sam. “Maybe if he translates it, we’ll have a better idea what’s going on?”

Sam shrugged and nodded. Dean offered to make coffee and Mitch got to work.

“Oh, my God,” Mitch said, two pots of coffee and three hours later. “I…. Oh, my God.”

“What, Mitch?” Sam asked gently.

“Well, I…this incantation? It…changes partway through. It starts out as a simple spell for virility, but then—” He rose quickly and pulled the book off his desk. He flipped it open furiously, not bothering with cotton gloves, but still being careful of the pages. He found the spot he was looking for, held up the page. He turned it slowly. Flipped it back. Flipped it forward. “Yeah, it definitely changes in the middle.”

Sam held out his hand. “Let me see it,” he requested. Mitch handed the book over reverently. Sam bent the spine back as far as he could, ignoring Mitch’s frantic cry to protect the binding. Very close to the stitching, Sam saw, a page had been cut away. “There’s a page missing,” he announced.

Mitch’s eyes bugged out in horror. “What the hell was I doing, then?”

“We don’t know, dude,” Dean said. “But whatever it was, it was making suicide spirits hijack humans, ride them to distant towns, and commit random acts of violence.”

“That’s…like the worst horror movie plot ever!” Mitch moaned.

“No kidding.”

“No more Namru worship, dude,” Dean said laconically.

“Yeah, no shit,” Mitch agreed. He looked back and forth between them nervously. “So…what are you gonna do now? Report me to the cops?”

Dean scoffed. “Yeah, great. We’ll tell them a 6,000-year-old spell caused those crimes.”

“Dean…” Sam sighed. “Sorry. We usually…hunt things that aren’t human to begin with.”

“Hunt?” Mitch repeated. He pulled his knees up to his chest. “Like…The Most Dangerous Game?”

“No, no, no, no,” Sam said, holding out his palms. “It’s okay, Mitch. My brother and I hunt…spirits.”

“Oh. Like the Ghost Hunters?”

Dean cast his eyes heavenward. “Yeah. Only without the stupid cameras. Look, Mitch, the point is, we can’t turn you in, there’s no one to turn you in to. And we can’t kill you—well, we could, but that’s not what we do,” Dean caught Sam’s eye and Sam saw a glint of frustration there. “So I guess all we can do is hit you upside the head with a clue-by-four.”

“Well, you might also want to make some kind of reparation to the people whose lives you messed up,” Sam added, trying not to sound like their father in one of his lecture modes. “But I guess, that’s up to you.” He pulled out his journal and copied down the names. “And behave yourself. Or we’ll be back.”


~*~THEN~*~

Beverly had wanted to do it properly, with limited guardianship and power of attorney and all, but John refused.

“It’s six weeks at the outside,” he said, sticking with the winter break date. He did go to a notary and signed documents giving her the right to make medical decisions if either boy should need attention immediately. “I’ll call every day,” he promised, “and if something happens, I can get on the first plane back.”

He left her money to take care of them, too. On January 2nd, the day before they went back to school, he brought them over with their belongings. Each boy carried his backpack and one duffel, and John brought in a third bag that he said had all the “other stuff.” While the boys lugged their things upstairs, he handed her a thick envelope. “Should be enough for the month and for Dean’s party,” he explained. “About that...I plan to be back in time for it, but I’ve never been good at planning that kind of—”

“Leave it to me,” Beverly said. If she had maternal feelings at all, lately they were more for John than his children. But she worked with kids every day, and had no difficulty believing that between her and Dean, they could make all the arrangements.

“Okay,” he breathed. His voice was so soft that the “K” sounded harsh in contrast. “I’ll call at 8:30 every night,” he assured her. “And if for some reason I miss two calls in a row...Dean knows what to do.”

That sounded uncomfortably ominous, but Beverly guessed that over the years, they had to have developed contingency plans. For when John couldn’t get out of work, or whatever.

The boys clattered back down the stairs. She took the envelope into her office to give the Winchesters privacy for their goodbye, as well as to look at the amount without John. Inside was cash—$2,000. Enough for food, Dean’s party at the arcade, even new clothes should they need any. That was unlikely; she’d noticed that new socks, flannel shirts, and even a pair of jeans each had been part of their Christmas loot. Though John was relying on her to watch his children, he clearly didn’t want his debt to extend any further than necessary.

When she came out, she heard Dean in the living room, objecting to something. She hung back, eavesdropping, because she didn’t want to interrupt and because she figured this was the only chance she’d get to hear Dean’s real opinion about the next month’s arrangements. “—take care of Sammy myself, Dad.”

“Not for a month, you can’t. That’s enough. I expect you to behave for Mrs. Kirkland like you would for Pastor Jim—in front of the congregation. Got that?”

“Yes, sir.” Dean sounded sullen, but resigned.

“Good. Look, pal, I’ll be back for your birthday, okay? You get to stay until then. That’s what you wanted, right?”

Dean said something unintelligible.

“Dean, I do trust you,” John said, a little frustrated. “I’m giving you a choice. You can stay here a little longer, with your school friends, and get that party in the arcade. Or, you don’t want it, say so now and we’ll pack it up. Either way, I can’t stay another month. You know that. So what’s it gonna be?”

There was a pause. Beverly wondered in that moment how much damage John had really done, in the heat of whatever had happened that summer, and how long it would take for Dean to heal. One birthday party might salve John’s conscience, but it wasn’t going to make up for John running away—and from what she’d seen, that was just what he was doing. She wondered if perhaps she should refuse to enable him…but then Dean would just lose his party on top of everything else, and she would lose the opportunity to make any sort of difference for him and Sam.

Dean muttered again, words so soft Beverly couldn’t make them out. But he must have made his decision because John grunted. “That’s my man. So I’ll see you in about three weeks, okay? Don’t worry, sport, I’ll call so much you’ll get sick of me.”

Beverly heard him move to Sam next. She didn’t dare peek around the doorway, but she could imagine John reviewing his little brigade of troops, bucking up the men before a campaign. He said he’d been fifteen years out of the Corps, but he sure hadn’t lost any of the military routine when it came to relating to his sons.

“Sammy, you be good, okay?”

“Sure.” Sam’s tone changed, as if making a point to Dean. “I like Mrs. Kirkland.”

John was unimpressed. “Whether you like her or not, you behave for her. No fighting with your brother, no griping about the grub, lights out when she tells you, brush your teeth every day, help her with KP and trash detail, or whatever else, right?”

“Okay, Dad,” Sam said as if he’d heard this a number of times already.

“I mean it, little guy—none of your usual crap. And don’t watch too much TV.”

“Yes, sir!” Sam barked with enthusiasm.

“Attaboy.” There was a sound of shifting fabric. Beverly sneaked around the corner, eager to watch them hug. Instead she saw that John was standing from a crouch. He threw his bag onto his shoulder on top of his new coat, and was now patting Sam briefly on the head. “Okay,” he continued, catching her eye. “Thanks again,” he said to bring her over to the family.

“My pleasure,” Beverly said breezily. It hit her that he was really leaving, seriously going to abandon his kids with a relative stranger. And she was letting him. His CO in Vietnam had been right: he had balls for days. “Well, you’d probably like to get on the road,” she continued, fighting a sudden urge to throw him bodily out of her house and sue for full custody of the boys.

“Yeah. Not much daylight to begin with,” he commented wearily, making no move toward the door. “No sense wasting what’s left by standing here.”

Beverly felt a burning behind her eyes and closed them quickly. She would not give him the satisfaction. “We’ll come out on the porch to wave goodbye,” she announced, moving toward Dean and Sam. They retreated before her, which in turn forced John toward the entry hall.

He opened her front door and stepped into the cold. Without looking back, he walked to the Impala and tossed his bag in the back seat, then climbed behind the wheel. A few seconds later, the engine rumbled, he backed out, cocked the wheel to the right, and with a single sharp saluting wave, turned away. The exhaust clouded up in the cold air and covered the tail of the Impala like mist as he drove off.

Dean and Sam ran back inside immediately. Beverly watched long after the taillights were no longer visible and the sound of the engine faded in the morning quiet.

She quickly learned that the boys were incredibly self-sufficient and mostly low-maintenance. Dean kept Sam to a fairly strict schedule, which made Beverly wonder how much of the parenting he did even when John was around. The one thing she insisted on was doing the cooking, because it became clear in the first three days that their idea of supper consisted of takeout, diners, grilled cheese, and Chef Boyardee. After the first couple meals, however, neither of them seemed to mind the profound lack of Wendy’s and frozen dinners in their diet.

About a week after John left, Dean knocked on her office door. “Yes, Dean, what is it?”

He looked at her with a copy of John’s most stoic expression. “Dad loves Mom,” he told her simply. It was a challenge without any doubt, a dare to contradict him or deny the truth.

“Yes, Dean. He loves her a lot,” she agreed.

The mildness with which she said it surprised Dean so much that he blushed and looked away. She felt sorry for him; he wasn’t sure whether he’d been cut off at the knees or vindicated. Evidently, the uncertainty of it bothered him, because he tried again. “No, I mean—”

“I know what you mean, Dean,” Beverly said with a tired sigh. “And I understand exactly how he feels. You see, I still love my husband a whole lot, too.”

Dean looked around. “There’s a Mr. Kirkland?” He looked like he expected Tom to walk through the door at any moment.

“There was,” she explained. “It’s okay, though. Your dad and I are friends.”

“Friends?” Dean echoed uncomprehendingly. It was as if he couldn’t contemplate men and women being friends. He probably couldn’t. Beverly didn’t expect there’d been too many female influences on the boys in relation to their father since Mary’s death. John had pretty well confessed as much.

She nodded. “Well, he trusted me to look after you and Sam, right?”

Dean considered the validity of her logic. He took a tentative step toward her desk. “Yeah, I guess,” he admitted, one shoulder rising and then relaxing.

“And I’m happy to have you two visit, but between you and me, I’m glad I’m not a full-time mom.”

If he had been expecting a speech to prepare him for gaining a step-mother, her divulgence completely threw him for a loop. She suspected he’d come here prepared for a fight, but she wasn’t going to fall into that trap. She did take pity on him and decided to ease his anxiety a bit. “Come and sit down,” she invited, pointing to the one chair that didn’t have books in it, waiting to be shelved. He perched on the edge of the cushion, arms crossed.

“Dean, I don’t know if your dad would ever seriously consider getting remarried,” she told him candidly, “but I know that some of our first conversations were about the people we’d lost. I know he was really worried that you’d get the wrong idea because he asked me to let you and Sam stay here.”

“He was?”

“Mm-hm,” Beverly confirmed, nodding. “Now, I like you. But honestly, the kids at the library, having you two here for a month...that’s about all the mothering I can handle.”

Dean started to smile, but caught it before his lips opened to reveal teeth. “Well, Sammy is kind of a pain in the a—uh, butt.”

Beverly gave him a wry grin, mouth twisting, but no teeth showing, either. “No, I think you both do just fine. Do you want spaghetti tonight?”

Dean shrugged. “S’fine,” he said. He got up, and whether he was grateful for the subject change or just fooled by it, he crossed to the door. “Mrs. Kirkland?”

“Yes?”

“Do you love him, anyway?” His voice was quiet, plaintive, as if afraid that it wasn’t okay to love someone and not be loved back in the same way, or the same amount. As if he were worried that she would hate John for making her love him.

As if he were worried that John didn’t love him back, and as if that were his fault.

Beverly swallowed. “It doesn’t really matter, does it? It doesn’t change anything. I’m your librarian, Dean. And your dad’s friend.”

That seemed to satisfy him finally, but he couldn’t resist one last volley. He grinned ghoulishly and asked, “Can I ask you one other question?”

“Of course.”

“What’s sex?”

Beverly couldn’t quite stop her eyes from widening, her face from flushing. She dropped her pen on the blotter, but in the second it took her to retrieve it, she took a deep breath and blinked back at him. Tom would have said that Bambi had come home to roost, or something equally inane. “Well, Dean, there’s a whole section on that at the library. Why don’t we take a look tomorrow after school and I can help you pick out some books on the subject.”

“You’re not gonna just tell me?” he challenged. He didn’t mean what sex was, either—of that, she was sure.

“No, I’m not,” she replied, refusing to take the bait. “Because like I just said, I’m not your mother.”


~*~NOW~*~

It was late, but not too late to go back to Mrs. Kirkland’s house when they left Mitch’s place. Sam argued that they should, if only to return the key and take advantage of another night’s free stay. “Maybe she’ll let us do laundry.”

Dean was still distracted by the one that got away. “I wish we coulda capped him,” he muttered on the way back to Dublin.

“Dude. Do you want your rap sheet to get any longer?”

“I’m just sayin’, Sammy, this sucks. He’s getting away with murder.”

“Manslaughter,” Sam murmured.

“Whatever, man. This blows.”

“Yeah, it does,” Sam agreed glumly. “If there were any way—”

“I know. Not even an anonymous tip would make this stick.”

“You think he’ll do anything? For Lauren or David?”

Dean sniffed. “Probably not. What’s he going to do? Confess to the cops that he conducted an ancient ritual that didn’t quite do what he thought, and that’s why they flipped out?” He scoffed. “Nah, face it, Sam, all we could do on this one was stop this idiot from making it worse.”

Sam was silent for a minute. Then with a sigh, he concluded, “Well, he’s going to have to live with knowing that his stupid bid for glory caused a lot of pain to perfect strangers. That, and he’s going to have to start over on his research.” He grinned.

“You snaked the book?” Dean asked, glowing with pride.

Sam reached into his satchel and pulled it out. “I figured we could use it. Who knows, it’s something we’ve never seen before.” He didn’t mention that if he could find the other half of the ritual, there might be something in it to combat Dean’s impending doom. He didn’t want to think about Dean dying, but if worse came to worst, resurrection spells might come in handy.

“Aw, Sammy. I knew I raised you right.”

Mrs. Kirkland’s lights were still on when they pulled into her driveway. They climbed out and Sam grabbed their clothing duffels out of the trunk. The porch light clicked on as they approached. “I heard the car,” Mrs. Kirkland explained when she opened the door. “Come on in.”

She preceded them into the living room. “So, did you…finish your hunt?” she asked.

Sam dropped the duffels. “How did you…?”

“Your dad’s letter,” she said. She poured herself a drink. “Want one?” she offered, and turned over two more tumblers, splashing the liquid in without waiting for their answer. A silver bracelet circled her wrist. The charm glinted in the light as she poured and picked up the glasses.

“Mrs. Kirkland, are you ok—”

“I’m fine, Sam,” she said. “I even believe him. See, I read his letter this morning. Then I went to my library. And I looked up a few things. The Johnson House, Franklin Castle…all those haunted houses? They really were haunted, weren’t they? And you two…are you really wanted by the FBI?”

Dean’s jaw clenched. “You gonna call them?” he asked. His voice was deadly calm, but Sam could tell he’d gone from tired to terrified in two seconds flat.

Mrs. Kirkland stared at him for a long time. “No,” she said finally. “Here,” she said, passing one of the tumblers toward him. Sam got a good look at the charm—it had a protective symbol etched on it. “Have a drink.”

“Look, we can go if—” Sam began to offer.

“No. I’m glad you came back. I’m glad, Sam.” She looked at Dean. “Dean, I don’t care if you’re wanted. If half the things I’ve read since yesterday are true…well, if they are, then I’m not surprised the FBI has its head up its ass where you two are concerned. But more importantly, I knew your father. I think I know him even better now than before. And I can’t believe he raised either of you to be killers.”

Dean knocked back the whiskey and sat heavily on the sofa. “You and Dad…you….”

“I didn’t plan to, believe me, Dean,” she said quietly. “I don’t think he planned to, either.”

Sam’s head snapped up. That had been Dean’s issue, not the sex. He didn’t want to relive the past, true—Dean never liked looking back—no more than he’d wanted to force Mrs. Kirkland to look it in the eye. But what had been bugging Dean since the jump was the idea that Dad had felt more than lust for someone other than Mom.

Her next statement should have allayed that fear. “But he was so committed to your mother,” she said. “And I think now, I finally know why. Did he…did he find the thing that killed her?”

Dean looked away. Sam nodded. “Yeah, he…he did. We got the bastard, too.”

“But it killed him?”

Dean dropped his head. “Yeah. Basically,” Sam supplied.

Mrs. Kirkland nodded. Tears spilled out of her eyes. “I think you ought to know, he was so scared you boys would hate him. Dean, he told me, when we…talked…about you two staying here, he said that he’d been waiting for you to be ready for him. I didn’t get it at the time, but now I do. He was looking for you to give him permission to hunt. He also told me that the main reason he wanted you to stay through January was so that you could hang on to your friends long enough for a real birthday party.”

Dean got up and poured more liquor.

“But I think he was in trouble either way, right? He was afraid that if he pulled you out, you’d think that he was punishing you. That he was so angry with you over whatever wrong he perceived you’d done, that he couldn’t stand to be around.” She sipped her drink. “But you still thought that, didn’t you, because he left without you? Dean, you do realize that whatever happened, he wasn’t running away from you?”

“I don’t need this,” Dean muttered. He looked like he wanted to bolt upstairs, but Sam held up his hand to tell him to chill out.

“Maybe not,” Mrs. Kirkland admitted. “But—hang on. Stay there. I want to read you something.” She got up and went into her office, returning immediately with the letter.

Sam could see that his father had written it on pages from the journal, and that his writing crossed the lines of the paper and became progressively messy and uncontrolled. It went on for several pages. She scanned them. “He wrote this the day before he came back for your birthday, Dean. Here. I know you know that I’ll always love Mary, that I’ll always put her boys’ safety before my own happiness. But now you know why. and this: I have a mission. I’ve gotta finish finding out what caused Mary to die—why she was murdered—and I’ve gotta destroy it forever. And meanwhile, even more importantly, I’ve gotta make sure my boys are safe. That they know how to take care of themselves. Until I do that, I can’t give you what you deserve, Bev. I can’t ask you to play second fiddle to a memory.

She wiped her face with the back of her hand. “He said he wished things could be different. Believe me, I wish things had been different, too. But please, please don’t think your father ever thought anything was more important than you boys, and your mother.”

She took another slug of the whiskey. “Now, I think I should go to bed. You two probably want to get some sleep, too. And in the morning, I’m going to make pancakes, and you will eat them.”


~*~LATER~*~

You want to know about whom? Winchester? You can’t mean John…. Let me see that picture again? Yes…that’s John. John Winchester. Wow. Now there’s a man I haven’t thought of in….

Did I know he was on the FBI’s dangerous persons list? Do I look like a woman who would harbor a dangerous person? Don’t answer that.

Yes, I knew him. A long time ago. No, I’m sorry—I’ve no idea where he is or if he’s even alive.

What do you think the precise nature of our relationship was, Agent…Reidy? Do you expect me to be delicate about it? We had an affair. And his boys stayed with me, for about four weeks in 1990.

Heh. If you think that, you haven’t done your profiling work very well. John…well, one look at John and you knew you were never going to have his undivided attention. Even without the boys. His wife…none of us were ever going to stand in for her. But a man, even a man like John, needs companionship once in a while. Still, even the fifty percent of him—or even less, I guess, with Dean and Sam in the equation—even that was plenty.

No, I haven’t heard from either of them, either. I doubt they’d even know how to get in touch with me. Don’t know that they even remember much about it. John was careful about that. Didn’t want anyone getting the wrong idea. I have to say that at the time, the last thing I wanted was to become a step-mother….

You’re kidding. No. I don’t believe a word of it. John didn’t raise reprobates, let alone killers. I mean, they were a bit rambunctious, but…homicidal? No. They were good boys.

I’m sorry. I really haven’t seen them. Not since January 29, 1990.

Yes, of course, I understand, Agent Reidy. Yes, if I hear from them, I’ll call. But I really don’t think that’s going to happen. The Winchesters aren’t men who retrace their steps much.

No, I really don’t have anything else to say. Of course, Agent. I’m glad you liked the coffee. Take care, now.








~*~FIN~*~

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 02:36 am (UTC)(link)
Please Download (http://www.sendspace.com/file/ntcew5) the Mix (http://www.megaupload.com/?d=8WFLXAIV) that Sazzlette made to go with this fic (links go to SendSpace and MegaUpload), and while you're downloading,

leave her some love for the art of awesome! (http://community.livejournal.com/lightontheblue/24577.html?mode=reply)
Edited 2008-06-27 23:45 (UTC)

[identity profile] tinylegacies.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 03:17 am (UTC)(link)
Excellent, excellent story.

I loved the switching back and forth between the timelines. I loved the relationship between John & Beverly. Everything was just fantastic.

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 03:26 am (UTC)(link)
I'm seriously impressed that you've finished already!

Thanks so much for the review - glad you enjoyed it.

[identity profile] art-savage.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 04:00 am (UTC)(link)
Very cool story! I love a good casefic (though this was much more than just that), and they're so few and far between - this really hit the spot. The balance between past & present seemed just right, and there was a nice "awww" factor without it being too schmoopy. Definitely one of the Big Bang highlights so far!

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 03:54 pm (UTC)(link)
Gosh, thank you so much - what a lovely compliment!

I always stress over whether the casefile and the character development/family drama aspects are balanced, so I'm thrilled to hear you say they both felt right.

And yes, I'm always looking to hit the sweet spot between realistic "aww" and over-the-top "Schmoop" - so thank you!

Very glad that you enjoyed it. I am SOOO far behind on reading I may never catch up.

[identity profile] marinarusalka.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 04:07 am (UTC)(link)
This was a really fun story. Beverly was a likable and sympathetic OC, and I really enjoyed her interactions with John and the boys. The casefile plot was fun and original, too. Nice job!

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 03:55 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you! I always value your opinions, so I'm thrilled that the various aspects in play here rang true and worked for you.

[identity profile] erinrua.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 06:57 am (UTC)(link)
But ... but ... it's over! *cries*

Again, this was so many kinds of awesome. Your details, your characters, your situations and resolutions, the psychology of your events and people are all just so real. You've brought this story to life as tactile and resonating as if it were a world I actually walked into and experienced.

I loved Beverly. I did. I ached for her, I ached for John, but I loved how you kept everything genuine and true to character - for both of them. I liked how you drew the Winchester family as just that little bit *off*, and the boys just that odd bit different. Sam and Dean are both boys, but there's something about them that's just not ... as frivolous as children are supposed to be. And somehow you've drawn them in such a fashion that I can see the beginnings of the men they'll one day be. And again, oh, how I *adore* your John, damaged and sincere and just .... so damn trapped in the mission his life has become.

As for the story itself? Perfect. I purely enjoyed all the tension and thinkiness and sleuthing and clues and the boys being all smart and clever: a team. And then? It just turns out to be a couple idiots messing with powers they don't understand. Somehow that "let-down" just worked, and felt oddly satisfying, more so than if it had crescendoed to some grand, demonic encounter. It wasn't demons. It was just stoopid people. And ghosts and stuff, but you know. ;-)

The past-present stuff was nicely balanced, too, and I loved how Dean freaks out - he does have his odd freakouts, doesn't he? - over Beverly and she's just ... good, and kind, and yet human as any of us. The ending for her, the shock John revealed in his last message to her was excellent.

Yeah. This is like having a really excellent sit-down dinner for the brain. Thank you SO much for sharing this. I would buy this, if it were a tie-in novel.

Brilliantly well done, my dear! Storytelling at its finest. Think I'll have to buy you a drink at EyeCon, for this. ;-)
Cheers ~

Erin

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 04:15 pm (UTC)(link)
Aw... you can buy me a drink anytime, hon!

Yeah, like I said, I let Dean have that little-boy "But she's not MY mommy!" reaction so that the audience would feel it, too, so that they didn't feel like they had to hate her on the boys' behalf. I personally loved the conversation when he walks in and is all, "Dad loves Mom" like he's protecting his family unit from the big bad interloper.... And she's not about to tell them they've already broken up, but she can tell exactly what he's about. Poor little guy.

I was really worried about the case fizzling, out, too, because I knew it couldn't be demons (because "Sin City" makes it clear that they hadn't seen any since "Mag7") but I wanted it to be *something* that fed into Sam's growing sense of powerlessness for the season. I'll tell you a secret: I really didn't think the casefile was going to work at all and even as late as three days before the deadline, I was still figuring out how to resolve it. But then I decided on the old "Missing Page Changes Spell" trick and it clicked into place.

I was still worried everyone would find it lame, though.

So yay. Seems like so far that's not happening.

And John. Yeah, John. Poor, poor man. I knew that even though I had to know what was in that letter, I was only going to reveal a tiny piece of it to the audience in this context. Maybe someday. But the whole point of that letter was that he poured his heart out in a way he never would have done verbally. And that's, of course, why he ultimately decided to let it lie.

But he fact that he kept it, sealed, addressed, etc., speaks volumes. (And not just about how much he cared - about how FUCKED UP the man was.)

I loved from the beginning the irony in the fact that Dean was *right* and Sam was *wrong* in a way - that John never really intended that letter to find its way to Beverly - but at the same time, *Sam* was right and *Dean* was wrong because delivering it gave them all a form of closure that they (and certainly Beverly) never had at the time.

Oh, boys. You are all so screwed in the head.

Anyway, there I go talking about my own stuff again.

It's too short for a tie-in, but thanks for the vote of confidence!

(no subject)

[identity profile] erinrua.livejournal.com - 2008-07-03 02:11 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] pinkphoenix1985.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 08:37 am (UTC)(link)
I loved every minute of it! thx!!!

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 04:05 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you!

[identity profile] iyalode.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 10:38 am (UTC)(link)
That is lovely, thoroughly enjoyed this from start to finish. Bev is a wonderful OC, I really liked her. Mature, not blind to John's faults and trying in her own way to make a difference with the boys.

Great story. Thank you for the read.

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 03:59 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you!

It's such a relief to hear that people liked Beverly and didn't find her to be a Mary Sue. I tend to worry over introducing nearly any OC like this into the 'verse, but in particular when one is involved with the main characters - and for some reason, John especially - it really made me nervous to see people's reception.

I'm so glad she--and the rest of the story--worked for you.

Thanks for reviewing!
ratcreature: RatCreature as Sam and Dean. (sam and dean)

[personal profile] ratcreature 2008-06-27 12:13 pm (UTC)(link)
I really enjoyed this mix of the two timelines, the mystery of the case and the outsider POV in the past. And so many great illustrations!

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 04:04 pm (UTC)(link)
The illo's are really more numerous than I had anticipated - and all very evocative. I told Sazz I hadn't expected her to get so caught up by the story - it's a fantastic compliment that she wanted to draw so many scenes.

Glad you enjoyed!
ext_1409: maple leaf (bitten lips. [supernatural])

[identity profile] cjmarlowe.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 05:07 pm (UTC)(link)
I really, really enjoyed getting to see this side of John and getting to explore another side of life when the boys were growing up. The whole characterisation of him really rings true for me, as well as the boys' reactions both as kids and as adults later on.

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 06:45 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you so much!

It hit me while I was writing "TuF" that the shtriga incident was probably as scary for John as it had been for Dean, but in different ways. Once I realized that his reaction could well have been (IMO, must have been), to put the brakes on, I knew what happened in that part. And Beverly came out of "TuF" too - part of that desire to try to rebuild, followed by the realization that he can't stop for his own fulfillment - it's all about the vendetta (and prepping Dean and Sam for their fight, but it's unclear how much he already knew about that in 1989/1990).

My favorite Wee!Chester fics are the ones where we see John really struggle with the way he raised them, not just because it was difficult but because he knew he was not doing it well...and yet he did it anyway.

So yay! that it worked for you, too. Glad you enjoyed!

[identity profile] tassosss.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 05:10 pm (UTC)(link)
This was awesome. I really really liked Beverly and the hunt was engaging. This was quite well written so thank you!

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 06:46 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh, thank you!

I have been nervous about a lot with this fic, but those were two things about which I was *most* nervous - that the hunt would be lame, and that Beverly would be received as a Mary Sue or some such.

So YAY that both aspects worked for you! Thanks for reviewing.

[identity profile] july-july-july.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 06:48 pm (UTC)(link)
YAY! It turned out just perfectly. I'm sorry it's taken me a day or two to get over here. I moved and I'm in between ISPs.

The artwork is lovely, but there is one problem in the chapter 1 post with "childten's" librarian. I'd be a terrible beta if I didn't point it out.

Seriously, though, it's really lovely. Thanks for letting me in on the process!

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 07:58 pm (UTC)(link)
You're not a terrible beta by ANY measure.

And thanks - the perils of those last-second additions/revisions (typing in the dark doesn't help either!).

It's so much stronger thanks to your comments.

[identity profile] garnet-words.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 07:34 pm (UTC)(link)
Loved this. Beverly was an awesome OC and I really enjoyed her perspective on the Winchesters.

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-27 07:59 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you so much! I'm so glad everyone (so far) likes her and didn't dismiss her as a Mary Sue.

Thanks for reviewing!

[identity profile] norwich36.livejournal.com 2008-06-28 04:59 am (UTC)(link)
This was a fantastic story. I really *loved* getting an outsider's perspective on John and the boys, and this is exactly the sort of relationship I can see John having with a woman: no one could ever replace Mary for him, but even John needed to be close to someone sometimes. And I really loved seeing all the fallout from the incident with the striga.

And Mrs. Kirkland is a terrific original character. I loved that her first reaction to the boys was suspicion that they were abused, because...yes. That is exactly what an outsider would think. But I also loved how pragmatic she was, realizing that any official actions she took would only cause them to run and contribute to their isolation. I really loved her attempts to try to make things better for John and the boys, but I think even more than that I love the way she *failed*--especially the whole Christmas sequence--because that was so realistic. There are no quick fixes for the losses any of them (inclusing Mrs. Kirkland) have experienced, and John's breakdown afterward was just so powerful and real.

Oh, and the little snippets we get of John's training exercises for the boys (urban orientation!!!) were wonderful, too--I just love the way you manage to flesh out Sam and Dean's childhood with little snippets like that.

Finally, I love that John wrote to her--confessed every single thing--because it showed how much she meant to him. And then he didn't send it. Oh John. That's just so heartbreaking. I do wonder, if he had survived killing Azazel, if he really could have ever moved on. The letter is sort of the hope for that, but the fact that he didn't send it makes me think not. But he kept it.

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-28 05:34 am (UTC)(link)
OMG, Squee: what awesome feedback!

Yes, that's just it, I wanted to make it clear (without ever showing the whole thing) that John poured his heart out in that letter--which is exactly why he then couldn't share it with her. But he did keep it, even if he wasn't thinking about what might happen if he couldn't come back to deliver it himself. Oh, John - you are so fucked up, mister!

As for the shtriga fallout, yeah--I realized writing "TuF" that the shtriga thing probably really did serve as a "reality check" for John, and that his reaction after the initial adrenaline rush wore off must have been along the lines of, "Fuck--I've pushed Dean too far, too fast." And when I figured that out...the rest of this fell into place.

I came up with Beverly somewhat in parallel to that process, and I'm thrilled beyond words that (so far) everyone seems to find her realistic and a fitting "companion" for John, even in how they couldn't make it work. Because yeah, that's the thing: the failure is as important here as the attempt. Even if she'd had all the information, the point was that John couldn't move on in any emotional way. It was ultimately going to come down to the vendetta. I was really nervous about her reception, so it's fabulous to hear that she seemed real and well-matched (without being a Mary Sue).

I'm also particularly pleased that the breakdown worked for you--anytime I show John being human, I worry about how it'll be received. So YAY.

Thanks so much for the detailed comments--it's like deep fried crack! :^D

[identity profile] junalele.livejournal.com 2008-06-28 05:44 pm (UTC)(link)
I seriously love this story. Mostly because of your John. I happily hated canon!John for how he treated his boys. And I'm glad you don't make him all dad-of-the-month but you show how hopelessly and helplessly he's entangled in what happened to Mary and with the shtriga. How he has no real clue how to proceed but - being the stubborn marine, he is - just shoulders on through. Can't say it makes me like him anymore but that's not what's about anyway.

Obviously, also awesome Beverly. And awesome case. And awesomely heartbreaking, yet fuzzy-warm dynamics between Dean and Sam.

This one is so going into the memories! Thank you for writing and sharing!

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-29 06:14 am (UTC)(link)
Thank you so much!

My goal in all my Wee!chester fic is to represent John realistically - as neither a villain nor a saint, but as a deeply flawed, yet intensely loving man who is way, way out of his depth. I happen to love the character, but there's no denying that some of his actions were simply unforgivable and flat-out mistakes. But I think that anyone who is fair to his character should feel an uncomfortable mix of wanting to smack him upside the head and wanting to offer comfort and an ease from his pain. It's that contradiction in him, that he really loved his sons, but that in trying to protect/prepare them, he also really screwed them up, that is what I find so fascinating.

Thanks, too, for the compliment about Beverly. There were several things that made me worry, but not least of them was how she would be received. So YAY that she worked for you!

(no subject)

[identity profile] junalele.livejournal.com - 2008-06-29 19:46 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] taniapretender.livejournal.com 2008-06-29 08:03 pm (UTC)(link)
oh, wow, this truely was an amazing piece :)...thank you so much for writing/posting it. I love the way you drove from present to past and back to present

the hunt itself was really complex and believable. I bet it took you some time to find the plot ;).

I really loved Beverly, and I like that Sam and Dean got to have a bit of an explanation for John's behavior. It's nice too of you to have this settled third season, where Dean finally admitts to having issues with the way his dad behaved, it works definitely well that way :)


oh, and the epilogue *hearts*

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-30 01:20 am (UTC)(link)
Thank you!

Yes, the plot of the case was probably the hardest part of this... it was really a struggle and I'm thrilled that it's being received well. I was afraid it was going to turn out really super-lame.

The back/forth thing was quite deliberate, but it did work out a little more elegant than I'd anticipated - I love it when the story surprises me and the transitions create echoes and callbacks that wind up connecting the two halves and giving them better cohesion than I could have planned.

And YAY that you liked Beverly! For some reason I was really anxious to introduce a female love interest - and for John, especially! I've found that the John fans tend to be as fiercely protective of his devotion to Mary as Dean. But it was important to me that we learn that even John needed to be close to someone sometime...even if he was ultimately too broken to make it work.

LOL - the epilogue was originally the *beginning* of a whole other version of Beverly - before she underwent a major change to represent this character and time in the Winchesters' lives. But it's again, one of those happy accidents.

So glad you enjoyed! Thanks for reviewing.

[identity profile] redrikki.livejournal.com 2008-06-29 09:51 pm (UTC)(link)
Well, I just finished the entire story in one sitting and I've got to say I enjoyed it. I really liked your take on John. Admittedly, a lot of the time I wanted to smack him, but you portrayed him as complex and layered, even if he kind of missed to point of parenting at times.

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-30 12:19 am (UTC)(link)
And yeah, I think that's *exactly* the way a fair and balanced portrayal of John should be - so that you want to smack him most of the time, but you can almost see it from his POV and at least understand, if not condone, how he managed.

Thanks for the lovely feedback!

[identity profile] may7fic.livejournal.com 2008-06-29 10:31 pm (UTC)(link)
This truly was a fantastic story, its ending being as satisfying as I'd hoped and expected. Beverly was a terrific OC, as were all the less important ones you included in this wonderfully complex case-fic. To call it that... "a case-fic" seems so trite because it's truly so much more but, as case fics go, it stands up (at the very top!) with the very best I've read, plus you've given us the added more than welcome bonus of an exceptional character study of all of the Winchesters and from the outside POV that is often most fascinating.

Anyone who knows my own fic, knows without a shadow of a doubt that I'm a John girl. But, what I try to do is show this man's complexity, his flaws as well as his strengths, his pigheadedness as well as intelligence, and I try to suggest the reasoning behind what are often perceived as (and often simply are) poor choices on his part. So, saying all that, I have to say that what I love best about this story is your fair and balanced treatment of the complex man that is John Winchester, showing both his heart and warts and making this one of the most human portrayals of him that I've had the pleasure of reading. This story is swiftly going into my memories... thank-you again so very much for sharing it.

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-30 01:13 am (UTC)(link)
Hoo.

Well.

First, I'm delighted beyond words that you (and others) have responded well to Beverly and her role in the fic. I'm also thrilled that the case *worked* - I was really, really struggling with it for the longest time, and it was the absolute last part to come together. I was very worried that it would come across as lame as I thought it was when I was drafting it all.

Next, as far as John...yeah, that's exactly how I feel a fair and balanced portrayal of John should be. What I hoped to achieve was a sight of his fragility and his desperate need...while not forgiving the unforgivable mistakes he made in the name of a greater good--or more often, simply in the name of his vendetta. I wanted to reflect the mix of wanting to smack him upside the head much of the time along with the desire to give him a hug and offer him peace. (Points up - one commenter says she has no urge to offer John any sort of comfort; I say that's pretty harsh considering all he had to be going on with.)

John is a very difficult character to portray with that sweet spot of balance - many fics either show him as unrelentingly hardassed and pigheaded for no reason or go too far into schmoop (especially for when the boys were really young). But I also don't think his emotional withdrawal and absence from the boys happened all at once - and it didn't happen in a straight trajectory, either. I think of it as tacking into the wind.

So thank you for affirming that I hit that target.

As I said in the A/N, this fic is actually a prequel of sorts to "Trost und Freude," because while writing that, I had to fill in some of the blanks in their past, and I started thinking about Beverly and her relationship with the Winchesters. When I tried to place her in the timeline, and I realized that John's reaction to the shtriga must have been at least as freaked out at Dean's...everything fell into place.

So, yeah - I am metaing, but I agree that John was highly human and very complex and ultimately broken, but still functional, if hard-headed.

Anyway. Thanks SO MUCH for the amazingly kind feedback!

(no subject)

[identity profile] may7fic.livejournal.com - 2008-07-03 02:32 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[identity profile] may7fic.livejournal.com - 2008-07-06 01:45 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] shakespearebint.livejournal.com 2008-06-29 11:32 pm (UTC)(link)
Thoroughly enjoyed this - the back and forth between now and then worked very well. Good job!

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-06-30 12:18 am (UTC)(link)
Thank you so much! Glad you enjoyed.

Enjoyed the story

[identity profile] zazreil.livejournal.com 2008-06-30 05:41 pm (UTC)(link)
Liked the mystery and Dean's frustration with the ending. Poor boy - he really wanted to have a clean cut baddy instead of a fuzzy thoughtless college oaf. I liked the interweaving of the past and future and of Dean's ambivalence to seeing Bev again as well as the hint that part of John's withdrawal was his fear of risking his heart and memories. I think if they did marry Bev was smart and kind enough to work around Dean and wear him down. On a different note - I wanted to belt John upside the head in this fic just as much as Bev did. Which really is how I feel about him in the series too - so all's good ^_^

Zaz

Re: Enjoyed the story

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-07-02 01:06 am (UTC)(link)
Yup, as I said about "TuF," I think the proper response to John is both to want to smack him and simultaneously to sympathize. I'll never be able to excuse everything about him, but I don't know many who could have done better given his extraordinary circumstances--and many probably would have done a whole lot worse!

As for the rel'ship with Bev, thanks - I hoped that what this would convey is that it was really John's own fear that he might give up on his vendetta if he moved forward, so he willingly (and willfully) trapped himself - as much as he was trapped - in order to maintain the life he chose for himself and Dean and Sam. But his heart was another big piece of the puzzle - and I think it was reasonable of him to fear that if he let any of them get too close - himself or Sam or even Dean - the entity that killed Mary would have come back.

Anyway - so glad you liked it!

[identity profile] llywela13.livejournal.com 2008-07-01 07:58 pm (UTC)(link)
I'm so slow.

I don't read a lot of wee!chester fics - well, actually, not a huge amount of fic in general. But I plunged headfirst into this one, and it held me captivated until the end. Kudos! I really like the way you used the outsider perspective for the 1990 sections; it really effectively captured how difficult it is for an outsider to ever really be sure they are interpreting someone else's relationship or family right, no matter what the circumstances. And the Winchesters, of course, were more of an enigma than most! Nice job.

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-07-02 01:20 am (UTC)(link)
Well, cheers! I'm honoured that you read this, when you don't read a lot of fic... I saw that you had commented and thought, "Whoa!" - but I had to go collect my deposit back from the con artists who wanted to bilk me on the car.

So I'm just getting to this, which I have to say, I've been burning with curiosity for your opinion!

And I'm quite pleased that it worked for you. This is a prequel to "Trost und Freude" (which you should also read!) and the idea for the 1989/90 timeline occurred while writing that, since I had to figure out John's reaction to the whole shtriga thing.

And I wanted to use Bev's perspective precisely because I wanted to be able to have her look back at her interactions with John and put the pieces together, but also because I wanted to explore the aftermath of the shtriga without being able to get directly into either John's or Dean's heads.

So thanks...and feel free to work your way through the rest of the fanfic (it's really just dramatised meta, anyway!).

(no subject)

[identity profile] llywela13.livejournal.com - 2008-07-02 05:44 (UTC) - Expand
ext_13391: (John_has_power)

[identity profile] smilla02.livejournal.com 2008-07-03 11:47 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh,this was so cool. I like how you put together the double timeline; the insight into John was very well done and Beverly was a lovely OC. I loved how everything came together for Dean and Sam and that they gained a new understanding of John by the end. Good job!

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-07-04 01:21 am (UTC)(link)
Thanks so much! Glad you liked it. I wanted to play with that third-season distance, where Dean and Sam can both look at their father with a little better perspective.
embroiderama: (John - Oh Papa)

[personal profile] embroiderama 2008-07-04 08:03 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh, MAN, I loved this story so so much. You write such a wonderful John and the boys are perfect in both their wee and grown versions. And Beverly seems very real and good with John. Thank you for such a great read!

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-07-23 11:42 pm (UTC)(link)
You're very welcome!

I don't know how I missed replying before....

I'm really glad that everyone seems to like Beverly and didn't feel she was unrealistic. I tried hard...but if I was nervous about anything with this, it was how she (and John having a relationship with her) would be received. So yay that it seems to have worked for most people!

[identity profile] lemmealone.livejournal.com 2008-07-10 04:34 am (UTC)(link)
Man, this was fabulous. I really loved the flashbacks especially, with the outside view of the boys and the way John raised them, and Dean's issues with their Dad loving anyone after Mary. VERY nicely done. *g*

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-07-23 11:44 pm (UTC)(link)
Aw, thanks!

I feel awful replying so late, but I was at this conference...and then life came and chomped on my ass.

Wee!Chesters are my crack. For serious. So I'm glad you liked the flashbacks, particularly.

[identity profile] lnhart.livejournal.com 2008-08-30 04:48 am (UTC)(link)
This was really wonderful. I wish they could have had a Mrs. Kirkland. You did a great job with John's voice. Thanks.

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-08-30 10:06 pm (UTC)(link)
Thanks so much!

...What do you mean, they didn't really have a Mrs. Kirkland? ;^D

No, seriously, I agree. I think the lack of female authority figures in their lives, the lack of someone around whom any of them could show their vulnerability, is palpable.

And yet at the same time, John wasn't dead, and he has to have had some companionship at some point. (Even Sam wonders whether John and Ellen had had a thing when they first meet her.) So I think there were some women along the way, whether they were aware of it or not, and those in their lives (teachers, etc.) who helped soften the boys' hard edges.

You simply don't get a Sam or a Dean without some positive role models - including, to some extent, John.

But anyway - that's me, rambling. Thanks so much for the feedback! Glad you enjoyed the fic.

[identity profile] barkley.livejournal.com 2008-11-30 04:59 pm (UTC)(link)
I really enjoyed this. Loved Beverly, loved her interactions with each of them.

[identity profile] gwendolyngrace.livejournal.com 2008-12-08 03:59 am (UTC)(link)
Thanks - I guess LJ must have been fouling up comment forwarding. That or I've been horribly neglectful!

But I'm so glad people have liked Beverly. I wanted her to be worthy of the Winchesters!

Page 1 of 2